We went to McDonald’s, 5 Guys and Burger King on Piccadilly Gardens and the winner was a no brainer – Dianne Bourne

Spread the love


In a world of dizzying burger choices, there are three American quick meals giants that stay the most important icons of the towering meat sandwich – McDonald’s, Burger King and 5 Guys. And in Manchester we have now obtained all three sitting in a type of burger Bermuda triangle slap bang on the coronary heart of Piccadilly Gardens. So the place higher to go to place these takeaway titans to a full burger-off? And we thought we might do a fries-off whereas we have been at it too. To totally check the burger experiences we’ve got additionally mirrored on the atmosphere of the Burger King, McDonald’s and 5 Guys settings of their unholy trinity formation at certainly one of Manchester’s busiest pedestrian junctions. We additionally made certain to notice down simply how briskly every quick meals large took to current us with our items. READ MORE:I attempted McDonald’s new McCafe Iced frappes as menu sees shake up This is how we obtained on at every burger parlour, and the way the merchandise all stacked up when put to the style check. We ordered every part to remove, to dine al fresco on Manchester’s pleasant city oasis of Piccadilly Gardens. Burger King

Burger King had some badly broken home windows on Piccadilly Gardens
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

Oh expensive, with huge holes damaged into the doorway doorways and home windows, and swiftly added boards to cowl up the fractured injury, it is not precisely essentially the most salubrious of welcomes at Burger King on Piccadilly Gardens. I imply, I have been right here late at night time in determined want of a burger so I do know it may be just like the Wild West at instances however no quantity of hangry could make it okay to start out pummelling within the home windows can it? Within the chilly gentle of day the interiors aren’t trying that shiny both and there is not a lot in the way in which of seating choices. Fortunately then that the ordering and cooking order was so swift that I may bid a hasty retreat out to the Gardens with our order. Was there a queue? Not a lot of 1 no, so I used to be in a position to order inside a few minutes of arriving. Time for order? Impressively, it was prepared whereas I used to be nonetheless juggling with my cup on the multi-mix Coke machines – in simply TWO minutes flat. McDonald’s

McDonald’s on Piccadilly Gardens all the time appears to be busy
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

Is the Piccadilly Gardens McD’s Manchester’s most loopy busy quick meals outlet? It definitely feels prefer it. There all the time appears to be a large queue of children exterior everytime you stroll previous right here, and at our 12noon go to it is no totally different – the queue is out the door to get in. Amazingly although, it is all very environment friendly as soon as inside. I am swiftly pointed in direction of a kind of digital ordering board issues and I can order inside a few minutes of beginning to queue. I accumulate my receipt considering I am in for a protracted wait. However think about my shock when my quantity is named inside ONE MINUTE of the order. Now that is what you name quick meals. Was there a queue? Sure, a large one however everybody was handled actually shortly Time for order? An virtually unbelievably fast one minute 5 Guys

The brand new child on the block – 5 Guys at Piccadilly
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

Because the shiny new child on the block, the flamboyant new 5 Guys on Piccadilly Gardens is predictably the glossiest trying venue out of the three burger joints right here. There are comfortable pink and white sales space seats and it is so shiny and clear that you just simply wish to stroke the tile-clad partitions. Regardless of being the one individuals within the queue, we had our order taken with the velocity anticipated from an Aldi checkout, discovering ourselves in a panic over the limitless free toppings however lastly deciding on tomato, ketchup and gherkins. Within the ready space, different hungry prospects awaited their order, and once they known as out quantity 52, I appeared down at our order 58 and realised we could possibly be right here some time. Our burger landed in my palms six and a half minutes later, with the milkshake arriving individually one other 30 seconds on. Was there a queue ? We have been the primary in line. Time for order? Six minutes 32 seconds The burgers

Left to proper: Burger King, 5 Guys, McDonald’s
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

To make it as truthful a comparability as potential, we ordered a double cheeseburger at every of the three burger eating places as a takeaway. We additionally requested for the common fries possibility at every institution. Now, clearly, with takeaway burgers they by no means look fairly nearly as good as these shiny publicity pictures on the billboard would have you ever consider. However unwrapping our burgers they have been a little bit of a sorry trying line-up for our footage. The McDonald’s Massive Mac was a very unimpressive instance of the oeuvre, the skinny burgers slapped in uneven formation with the bun and strands of lettuce poking out everywhere like octopus tentacles – whereas one gherkin did not even make it onto the burger. The bun appeared very dry and the burgers missing in moisture, however after all it was all saved considerably by the ever-trusty hit of the traditional McD’s Massive Mac sauce.

Not the Massive Mac’s best hour on Piccadilly Gardens
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

The Burger King double cheeseburger appeared pretty compact and a tad joyless, and just like the McD’s bun was very dry. However on tasting we each agreed it provided a extremely attention-grabbing flavour hit because of lashings of mustard together with the standard cheese and tomato burgery mash up. Nonetheless, it was maybe predictably the 5 Guys burger that wiped the ground with its American rivals. Taking it out of their signature foil wrapping it was all a bit squished up, however as soon as we took a chunk that did not matter. The meaty, juicy flavourful burgers got here into their very own, married with the gherkins, tomato sauce and cheese within the delightfully moist bread bun that sandwiched all of it collectively. Burger perfection that was well worth the post-ordering wait. Scores 5 Guys: 5/5 Burger King: 3/5 McDonald’s: 1/5 The fries

Fries from (left to proper) McDonald’s, 5 Guys and Burger King
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

Whether or not you eat your fries earlier than or after your burger, dunk them in your milkshake for dessert or munch on them between mouthfuls of meat, they’re a vital a part of a quick meals meal. McDonald’s fries are so iconic that even Apple have an emoji that appears similar to them in a pink carton, sans golden M, after all. However it was the Maccies fries that fell the flattest on this chip trio, providing a lukewarm, limp and lifeless potato stick. It is truthful to say that McDonald’s fries are solely palatable when piping scorching with shaking of salt, nevertheless it’s uncommon they’re served this fashion, making it an actual side-order lottery. In the meantime Burger King and 5 Guys appear extra constant of their composition, providing thick and fluffy fries which are rather more substantial. That stated, whereas Burger King’s fries are fairly moreish, their portion sizes could possibly be greater for an everyday fries, and the flimsy paper bag makes them troublesome to juggle with different meal objects.

The 5 Guys fry stands tall (centre) the McD’s chip wilts in Dianne’s hand
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

5 Guys had the biggest portion of fries smothered in a cajun seasoning for a spicy kick, served in a sturdy cardboard cup. The fries have been overflowing from their container which means we ended up with fairly just a few ‘bag chips’ on our palms. However once more, it was a no brainer who the winner was right here. The 5 Guys cajun fries actually stood head and shoulders above the remaining, with a crisp outer and fluffy, flavoursome potato inside, although it should be stated my favorite are the tremendous crispy bits you discover within the backside of the cup. Scores 5 Guys: 4/5 Burger King: 3/5 McDonald’s 2/5 The costs 5 Guys: Cheeseburger (customary comes as a double) £8.95, common fries £4.75 (no meal deal possibility) – our milkshake value a whopping £5.25 Burger King: Double cheeseburger – £1.99, common fries – £2.49 (or as a meal cope with a drink £4.99) McDonald’s: Massive Mac – £3.19, common fries – £1.09 (or as a Further Worth Meal with a drink £4.69) The decision

Burger King (left) 5 Guys (centre) and McDonald’s (proper)
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

Dianne writes: I’ve lengthy been a fan of the straightforward calorific pleasure of a McDonald’s takeaway, however on this style check it was one which disillusioned me essentially the most. I would been impressed with the speediness creating my order given how busy the Piccadilly Gardens restaurant was, however I now assume maybe extra haste much less velocity was wanted to create a greater trying Massive Mac because it simply appeared in a proper previous state. When in comparison with the burgers of Burger King and 5 Guys it merely paled as compared on style as nicely. Whereas each BK and McD’s have been slightly dry buns, I truly actually loved the mustard hit of the Burger King model. Solely the McDonald’s sauce gave it something tasty to savour although. However 5 Guys was the one burger the place, though twice as costly, made it greater than well worth the funding. I additionally do not thoughts ready a measly six minutes for one thing that tastes this darn good. Nonetheless on the fries entrance, for me it was a tie between the Burger King and 5 Guys chips which have been each tasty potatoey treats – however the expense of the 5 Guys fries (£4.75) in comparison with BK’s (£2.49) would swerve me extra in direction of the cheaper ones for worth. The McDonald’s fries tasted to me what I can solely think about a 3D printer model of a chip would style like – a type of bland, wilting cardboard.

The 5 Guys burger was a transparent winner
(Picture: Manchester Night Information)

Bethan writes: I would beforehand been beneath the impression that 5 Guys was an overpriced McDonald’s – however how incorrect was I? It appears to me that you just actually do get what you pay for on this state of affairs, even when they’re nearing pub costs and took some time to be ready. That stated, if a burger might be ordered and in my hand inside 60 seconds, is that basically interesting? I am not sure. The 5 Guys fries shone in comparison with the opposite choices – though I’m a fan of a scorching, salty McDonald’s fry dunked in a strawberry milkshake from time to time. The burger, although, was meaty, juicy and virtually melted in my mouth, which is every part you need on the finish of a nicely oiled night time out in Manchester, proper? Between McDonald’s and Burger King was a more durable choice, as Burger King’s fries have been superior, however the Massive Mac sauce was extraordinarily tasty between the layers of beef and bun. However you may’t simply smother a dry burger in scrumptious sauce to put it aside, so Burger King simply clinched it on high quality. Although credit score the place it is due, Maccies stays the most affordable possibility, and due to this fact in the event you’re tight on money or need a mega fast chunk to eat, they’ve nonetheless obtained your again. Get the newest What’s On information – from food and drinks to music and nightlife – straight to your inboxwith our each day e-newsletter.
Learn Extra
Associated Articles

Learn Extra
Associated Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.