COVID: ‘Absolutely vaccinated’ must be redefined, consultants say

Spread the love

As extra proof emerges on the efficacy of third doses of the COVID-19 vaccine, consultants say it’s excessive time public well being authorities revise the definition of “absolutely vaccinated” to incorporate a booster dose.

Whereas most SARS-CoV-2 vaccines out there in Canada have been initially developed and examined to incorporate two doses – apart from the Johnson & Johnson vaccine – a major course ought to as a substitute encompass three doses, mentioned Colin Furness, an skilled in infectious illness epidemiology from the College of Toronto.

“Somebody who’s solely had two pictures will say, ‘I’m absolutely vaccinated,’ and that is what the authorities are saying, [but] the authorities have gotten it fallacious,” Furness informed in a phone interview on June 1. “Once we take a look at the diminishment of immunity after the second dose, actually, it is a three-dose vaccine.”

A newly launched meta-analysis performed by the Chinese language College of Hong Kong earlier this 12 months assesses the efficacy of various vaccine combos in defending in opposition to COVID-19. Involving 53 research that embrace greater than 100 million individuals, the meta-analysis confirmed that three doses of an mRNA vaccine have been extremely efficient in defending in opposition to COVID-19 an infection, whether or not symptomatic or asymptomatic, at 96 per cent.

Three doses of an mRNA vaccine additionally had a 95 per cent efficacy charge in decreasing COVID-19-related hospitalization. The research concludes that three doses of a COVID-19 vaccine are crucial to guard in opposition to an infection from the Omicron variant of the virus.

Regardless of this, the Public Well being Company of Canada’s (PHAC) definition of “absolutely vaccinated” on the subject of COVID-19 vaccines continues to confer with those that have acquired a major sequence of the vaccine. The first sequence includes two doses of most vaccines accepted to be used in Canada (reminiscent of mRNA vaccines, in addition to the AstraZeneca, Novavax and Medicago vaccines), or one dose of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine.

“Because the epidemiological context of COVID-19 continues to evolve, the Authorities of Canada will proceed to observe the efficacy and effectiveness of vaccines being utilized in Canada and should present additional suggestions on the definition of a completely vaccinated particular person,” PHAC spokesperson Anna Maddison wrote in an e mail to on June 1.

It’s essential to notice that because the COVID-19 pandemic has progressed, the SARS-CoV-2 virus has developed away from what vaccines have been initially developed to focus on, Furness mentioned. This viral evolution has led to a discount within the efficacy of present vaccines, notably on the subject of defending in opposition to an infection from Omicron, the latest variant of concern. Regardless of this, three doses of the vaccine proceed to supply stable safety, notably in opposition to extreme outcomes of COVID-19 reminiscent of hospitalization and dying, Furness mentioned. Consequently, he mentioned he hopes to see a change within the definition of “absolutely vaccinated.”

“Hypothetically, if we had a vaccine that prevented lengthy COVID, hospitalization and dying, however did not cease anyone from getting contaminated, I might name that wildly profitable; we’d all get a chilly … however nobody would get actually sick,” Furness mentioned. “There is no query we do not have that, however three doses of a COVID-19 vaccine takes us nearer to that.

“Once we speak about ‘absolutely vaccinated,’ we must be speaking about three [doses].”

In Canada, simply over 20 million third and fourth doses of the COVID-19 vaccine have been administered to date, based mostly on knowledge compiled by In line with PHAC, about 55.5 per cent of Canadians aged 12 and older are vaccinated with three doses of the COVID-19 vaccine, which interprets to roughly 18.5 million individuals.


College of Saskatchewan epidemiologist Dr. Nazeem Muhajarine additionally advises those that are eligible for his or her third dose of the COVID-19 vaccine to go and get it. Nevertheless, moderately than tying the definition of “absolutely vaccinated” to a particular variety of doses, he mentioned public well being authorities ought to deal with advising Canadians to maintain their vaccination standing “up-to-date” based mostly on the newest suggestions from the Nationwide Advisory Committee on Immunization (NACI).

“’Absolutely vaccinated’ not works, in my thoughts, as a definition of being up-to-date on the vaccine doses that it is advisable get … I believe it’s excessive time that we [change] that,” he informed on June 1 in a phone interview. “It’s about being caught up with all of the vaccines that you just’re really helpful to get at this stage of the pandemic.”

The World Well being Group’s present definition of a major vaccination sequence refers to at least one or two doses of COVID-19 vaccines accepted for emergency use, relying on the product. Within the context of worldwide journey, the federal government of Canada considers these with no less than one dose of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine, or two doses of any of the remaining vaccines accepted to be used in Canada to be absolutely vaccinated. Provincial governments reminiscent of that of Ontario, nonetheless, have up to date the wording of their newest steerage to counsel that individuals get vaccinated with, “all really helpful COVID-19 vaccine doses, together with any booster dose(s) when eligible.”

Moreover, provinces throughout Canada have now made third doses out there to these aged 12 and older, and NACI strongly recommends third doses for all adults in Canada.

Whereas Furness mentioned he admits that COVID-19 vaccine safety may additionally wane following a 3rd dose, he nonetheless recommends that those that are eligible to get their booster shot accomplish that, given the extra safety it presents in comparison with simply two doses.

“It might wane, however that might nonetheless actually interrupt transmission and it will interrupt outbreaks, if we might get sufficient individuals [vaccinated] with a 3rd dose,” he mentioned.

A 3rd dose of the COVID-19 vaccine can even assist to additional shield populations from new variants or sub-variants which will floor sooner or later, Muhajarine mentioned.

“So long as we’ve a number of variants spreading, that opens the likelihood for brand spanking new variants to emerge – that’s how the evolution of those variants occur,” he mentioned. “I do not actually see any evidence-based purpose for conserving ‘absolutely vaccinated’ to solely two major doses.”

Uptake for the third dose of the COVID-19 vaccine has been sluggish compared to that of the primary and second doses, mentioned each Furness and Muhajarine. A part of the rationale for that is that the vaccine was initially offered to the general public as being comprised of two doses, making individuals assume that was all they wanted to be sufficiently protected, Furness mentioned.

“That is the psychological mannequin that most individuals had,” he mentioned. “So after we began to say you sort of want a 3rd dose now … [they] mentioned, ‘You offered us an concept that there was a two-dose vaccine and I signed on, now you are altering the deal and I do not like that, I am strolling away.’”

Contributing to this lack of enthusiasm in direction of getting boosted was the lifting of vaccine mandates by provincial governments throughout the nation earlier this 12 months, Muhajarine mentioned. These unable to enter eating places or film theatres as a result of they have been unvaccinated, for instance, are not barred, with proof of vaccination not required.

“Vaccine mandates labored by way of really getting people who find themselves eligible to get a second dose,” Muhajarine mentioned. “However when governments began to tug again these public well being measures and vaccine mandate measures, I believe individuals actually misplaced that incentive.”


Whereas he does name on public well being authorities to incorporate third doses within the definition of “absolutely vaccinated,” Furness mentioned it can take greater than altering the definition to encourage individuals to truly get their booster shot. A part of the answer lies in vaccine mandates being carried out and enforced by employers and governments.

“[If] your employer has mandated vaccination and that will get modified to 3 doses, then we’ll even have a major public dialog about what is the threat and profit,” Furness mentioned. “As soon as we’ve sufficient important public dialog, individuals will begin to contemplate it … [otherwise] it’s going to seem to be only a bureaucratic transfer.”

Having an open dialog concerning the position vaccines play within the combat in opposition to COVID-19 might be particularly useful in concentrating on those that are uncertain or afraid of getting vaccinated, Furness mentioned. A part of the answer additionally lies in elevated schooling on the operate of vaccines in addition to improved public well being messaging and extra native engagement, Furness mentioned.

“It is that afraid, uncertain, considerably skeptical [group] that isn’t positive who to consider, and anybody in that class goes to default to doing nothing till you make an excellent case – that is the place there’s work to be carried out,” Furness mentioned.

Primarily based on his observations, urge for food for vaccine mandates throughout Canada stays low in the meanwhile, mentioned Muhajarine. However one state of affairs wherein he might see these guidelines being reintroduced on a provincial stage is that if governments see one other wave of instances, or if one other variant or sub-variant have been to floor, he mentioned. In that state of affairs, it’s vital that officers not wait too lengthy to behave, mentioned Muhajarine.

“Provincial governments have the authority and duty to introduce insurance policies that can maintain their inhabitants protected,” he mentioned. “All through COVID-19, what we’ve realized is that fast motion actually issues. We can’t wait round till COVID begins to actually harm us with the intention to act in opposition to it.”

Furness additionally mentioned that as pharmaceutical corporations get nearer to growing an Omicron-specific vaccine, it’s more likely to encourage extra individuals to get their third dose in the event that they haven’t carried out so already.

“If we will come again and say, ‘Look, the vaccine is again to being what lots of people wish to perceive,’ which is what’s my discount in threat of getting contaminated … I believe it can put extra wind within the sails,” Furness mentioned. “And it will make it simpler to take care of vaccine mandates.”

Whereas Furness mentioned a case could possibly be made for ready till a variant-specific vaccine is developed earlier than contemplating revising the definition of absolutely vaccinated, he and different consultants advocate that those that are eligible get vaccinated sooner moderately than later.


What questions do you have got about Omicron?

With the emergence of a brand new COVID-19 variant of concern, labelled Omicron, needs to listen to from Canadians with any questions.

Inform us what you’d wish to know on the subject of the Omicron COVID-19 variant.

To submit your query, e mail us at together with your identify, location and query. Your feedback could also be utilized in a story.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.